设万维读者为首页 广告服务 技术服务 联系我们 关于万维
简体 繁体 手机版
分类广告
版主:红树林
万维读者网 > 五 味 斋 > 帖子
Why Americans Hate The Media
送交者: 福禄 2017年08月28日09:13:40 于 [五 味 斋] 发送悄悄话

Fake News Claiming Border Checkpoints During Hurricane Harvey Is Why Americans Hate The Media

A 'news story' about an incorrect ACLU statement regarding border patrol checkpoints during Hurricane Harvey illustrates why Americans hate the media.

John Daniel Davidson
By 

In southeast Texas, a humanitarian and economic catastrophe is underway. The National Weather Service has called Hurricane Harvey and the ensuing tropical storm “unprecedented” and “beyond anything experienced.” Flooding in some parts of Houston have reached 500-year floodplain levels, leaving thousands displaced or still stranded in their homes. But that hasn’t stopped the mainstream media from turning the disaster into a political talking point attacking the Trump administration.

On Friday, the American Civil Liberties Union released a grossly inaccurate and inflammatory statement in response to the unremarkable news that the U.S. Customs and Border Patrol would not close any internal checkpoints in Texas during the hurricane.

“As people seek refuge from hurricane Harvey, they are likely to have to go north or west of Texas and would have to go through a checkpoint. By keeping checkpoints open, the Border Patrol is putting undocumented people and mixed-status families at risk out of fear of deportations,” said Lorella Praeli, the ACLU’s director of immigration policy and campaigns. “This is a disgusting move from the Border Patrol that breaks with past practices. The Border Patrol should never keep checkpoints open during any natural disasters in the United States. Everyone, no matter the color of their skin or background, is worth saving.”

The problem is, there are no checkpoints in the areas affected by the storm, and no one fleeing Hurricane Harvey will encounter a Border Patrol checkpoint. The closest checkpoints are about 80 and 50 miles southwest of Corpus Christi and cover northbound routes from the Rio Grande Valley. No one fleeing the hurricane or the flooding along the coast would be headed north on these routes because they don’t lead inland to higher ground.

What’s more, the reporter, Heather Timmons, doesn’t seem to understand what happens at Border Patrol checkpoints. She writes that agents “check individuals’ documents to make sure they are legal residents of the US.” As anyone who has been through a Border Patrol checkpoint knows, actual document checks are uncommon. Typically, the agent asks a brief couple of questions before sending one on one’s way. Even the phrase “legal residents” is inaccurate. The Border Patrol is concerned about legal presence, not legal residence. After all, there are plenty of Mexicans legally driving on Texas roads, here for short-term or day visits, going about their perfectly legitimate business.

Finally, she writes this preposterous passage: “Civil rights activists said the new policy was cruel. It also could result in avoidable fatalities, if some families with illegal immigrant members choose not to evacuate the storm zone.”


This Is Why Americans Hate the Media

It’s no surprise that partisan left-wing outlets like Daily Kos would run hysterical and false coverage under the headline, “Border Patrol is trying to arrest undocumented immigrants fleeing Hurricane Harvey,” but Quartz is supposed to be rather more mainstream. Timmons is Quartz’s White House correspondent and an alumnus of The New York Times and BusinessWeek. She appears to be a professional journalist and should by all accounts be credible. Yet she has written a story—in fact, re-written an ACLU press release as a legitimate news story—that has almost no credibility. How did this happen?

The blame of course does not rest just with her, but with an editorial team that abdicated its responsibilities to her and their readers to score cheap points against Trump. The problems are glaringly obvious, and would have been easy to fix. But reporting on real events underway in Texas was not the purpose of the article.

So we have here an article that does the opposite of what its editors intended. They intended to show how callous and inhumane President Trump is toward immigrants, even in the face of a natural disaster, when lives are on the line. What they communicated instead is that mainstream journalists are willing to disseminate hyperbolic talking points from left-wing activists without even the pretense of reporting, fact-checking, or objectivity.

This in turn reinforces to ordinary Americans the sense that the media has so badly lost perspective about Trump that they are willing to lie and fabricate stories in order to attack a president who is otherwise vulnerable to a plain reporting of the truth. In short, this is why Americans don’t trust the media.

John is a senior correspondent for The Federalist


0%(0)
0%(0)
标 题 (必选项):
内 容 (选填项):
实用资讯
回国机票$360起 | 商务舱省$200 | 全球最佳航空公司出炉:海航获五星
海外华人福利!在线看陈建斌《三叉戟》热血归回 豪情筑梦 高清免费看 无地区限制
一周点击热帖 更多>>
一周回复热帖
历史上的今天:回复热帖
2016: 这算不算得上反诗?以前写的哈:
2016: 只有右派才有资格称为共产党员,这是时
2015: 最古老的问题之一:是大脑产生意识,还
2015: 关于共军8年抗战共击毙日军851名
2014: 上海人的素质就是比外地人高
2014: 民主自由,本质上是金钱金融至上
2013: 马邪教恶魔匪毛邓共企图改变每一位华人
2013: 纠个英语小错
2012: 如果美武力协同日本保钓,中国该如何应
2012: 中共发话了:保钓害国