设万维读者为首页 广告服务 技术服务 联系我们 关于万维
简体 繁体 手机版
分类广告
版主:诤友
万维读者网 > 教育学术 > 帖子
Invalidity of E = mc2
送交者: c_y_lo 2018年10月25日12:45:52 于 [教育学术] 发送悄悄话

Invalidity of E = mc2 -- A major Error of Einstein

Dear Professor Wilczek:

I am writing to you because I have found that E = mc2 can be invalid [1, 2]. I understand that you and your colleagues have used this formula to derive the asymptotic freedom in the theory of strong interaction [3]. But you have not justified the validity of applying E = mc2. In view of that this formula may not be valid for this case, such a justification is necessary. Although this deficiency is originated from Einstein, you simply accept Einstein’s erroneous claim as valid. However, the application of this formula must be proven to be valid. Since your derivation is at least incomplete, it is your responsibility to assure its validity.

Many considered E = mc2 as Einstein’s major achievement. However, if one looks carefully, it is clear this is a major error of Einstein due to his over-looking that this formula is inconsistent with the Einstein equation ( Rμν - (1/2)gμνR = -KTμν ). Since Einstein equation implies the curvature  

R=KgμνTμν.                          (1)

 The electromagnetic energy cannot affect the curvature R since the trace of an electromagnetic energy-stress tensor is zero, but the mass can. Thus, mass and the electromagnetic energy cannot be equivalent. In fact, equation (1) was first derived by Einstein himself. His failure to see this inconsistency is clear due to his over-sight.

Einstein claimed that a piece of heated-up metal would have an increased weight. However, experimentally, A piece of heated-up metal actually leads to a decrease of weight. Therefore, Einstein is wrong on this issue. Moreover, a charged capacitor and a charged metal ball also have reduced weight. So, Einstein is clearly incorrect.

Also, there are some minor errors in your Nobel speech [3]. 1) In Einstein’s 1905 paper, he used L/c2 as the mass. His proof is incomplete because he did not show how the radiation energy L is related to the energy of an electromagnetic wave. 2) It is in 1912 Einstein changed L to a general energy E. Thus, his claim of E/c2 can always regarded as a mass is incorrect.

If you have any questions, I shall be happy to answer them. Thank you for your kind attention.

Sincerely yours,

C. Y. Lo

MIT Physics 77

P. S. I may go to Hong Kong in December to report the errors on E= mc2. If a reporter asks me the opinion of MIT on this matter, I shall answer him as you would say.

c.c.:  David J Gross, H. David Politzer

References

1.         C. Y. Lo, David P. Chan, and Richard C. Y. Hui, “Oversights of Einstein & Maxwell and their Errors,” the 11th Symposium in honor of Vigier, Aug. 6-10 at Liege, Belgium, 2018.

2.         C. Y. Lo and Richard C. Y. Hui, Comments on the Invalid Proof of Einstein on L = mc2 and E= mc2, Phys. Essays Vol 31, No. 1, 2018.

3.         Frank A. Wilczek, “Asymptotic Freedom from Paradox to Paradox, “ Nobel Lecture (Dec. 8, 2004).



0%(0)
0%(0)
标 题 (必选项):
内 容 (选填项):
实用资讯
发龙药业大回馈!美国专利骨胶原、活心素、灯盏素、排毒养颜宝购买两疗程免费邮寄中国
天天养生,保健礼品,物超所值,疯狂现金折扣,直销美加,港台,大陆,东南亚
最劲爆,最给力美国专利产品<骨精华>消除关节痛、骨质疏松<心血通>预防心肌梗塞
免开通费,30天免费试用中文电视万花筒, 无捆绑服务,月费5.99
西洋参、羊胎盘、鱼油卵磷脂200多种送礼自用健康佳品,全部特价!由此进入
留美学生医疗保险$39/月,短期访美旅游保险,不需体检无年龄限制
一周点击热帖 更多>>
一周回复热帖
历史上的今天:回复热帖
2017: 不要对“PA2015”说我不感兴趣
2017: “北京哥们”当年举荐习近平上大学 如今
2016: 为何我说没有我给的钥匙, 诸位根本没法
2016: 基辛格是本届奥巴马希拉里的大决策总参
2015: 擘倾聃:国家不幸太子成窝
2015: 芨芨草:读书2
2014: 谁知道中国梦原始策划发明人汪乃君被雪
2014: 谁知道中国梦原始策划发明人汪乃君被雪
2013: 中军:马克思为什么是伟大的