设万维读者为首页 广告服务 联系我们 关于万维
简体 繁体 手机版
分类广告
版主:诤友
万维读者网 > 教育学术 > 帖子
飘侠:也谈谈今年的诺贝尔奖和钱永健教授
送交者: 飘侠 2008年10月08日15:49:37 于 [教育学术] 发送悄悄话
又到了诺贝尔奖开奖的季节,有关诺贝尔奖的消息和获奖科学家的名单不断传来,作为一个在诺贝尔的故乡读过博士,参加过2次诺贝尔奖頒奖仪式的人来说,自己的诺奖情节是不轻!在11月陆续宣布完获奖名单后,12月初便是瑞典的诺贝尔奖节日和圣露西娅节日(各地各学校都会选一位美女作为当年的露西娅),12月 10日斯德哥尔摩頒奖仪式完后,获奖者便会被邀请到包括我的母校在内的各个大学做演讲,那些年,几乎每年都能听到诺贝尔化学奖和医学/生理奖的科学家的精彩报告。 今年的诺奖获奖名单陆续公布了,首先是医学奖,两位发现人类免疫缺陷病毒(HIV)爱滋病病毒的法国巴斯德研究所的科学家Françoise Barré-Sinoussi 和Luc Montagnier和发现人类乳突淋瘤病毒(HPV)导致子宫颈癌的德国癌症研究中心的科学家Harald zur Hausen获奖。这也是几年来的第一次,医学或生理奖与美国无缘,美国似乎华尔街沦陷,诺贝尔医学奖也没份儿了。诺贝尔奖也又一次与被中文媒体炒做成科学圣殿的哈佛大学擦肩而过!哈佛大学已经10来年与诺贝尔奖无缘了,虽然她依然在众多的大学排名中名列第一,还是全世界最富的大学,当然很多获奖者都是哈佛大学的毕业生。两位法国病毒学家的获奖更使全世界正直的科学家松了一口气!当年美国病毒学者中的大腕Robert Gallo博士不仅用法国人的照片发文章, 还用法国人的样品测序, 测出来说是自己的样品而发现了人类免疫缺陷病毒(HIV)爱滋病病毒品.----这些事其实学术界的人都清楚。我当年做研究生时就对这种Robert Gallo这种行为感到不解,上苍有眼,诺贝尔奖没有给予他。当然还是有很多人为他而鸣不平的...请看英文媒体的评论: Twenty-five years after the discovery of the virus that causes AIDS, two French researchers were awarded the Nobel Prize in medicine yesterday for their role in that scientific breakthrough. Perhaps more notable than who won the award is who did not: Dr. Robert C. Gallo, the University of Maryland virologist who has long been credited as a co-discoverer of the human immunodeficiency virus and whose early work led to a blood test for HIV that is believed to have saved millions of lives. Though many in the field said they thought that a long-simmering debate over Gallo's exact role in the initial discovery had been settled and that Gallo and the French team should share credit, the Nobel committee apparently felt differently. Some scientists said yesterday that Gallo deserved to at least split medicine's highest honor. "The people who won the prize are very deserving," said Dr. John E. Niederhuber, director of the National Cancer Institute in Bethesda, where Gallo did his AIDS research. "But it seems strange to have left Bob out." Acknowledging that Gallo had "done a lot of other work" in the field, Joernvall noted that he and the two French scientists now "agree that the discovery was made in Paris." But Montagnier, who has been a colleague and rival of Gallo's for decades, said the American researcher should have been recognized. "It is certain that he deserved this as much as us two," Montagnier told the Associated Press in Abidjan, Ivory Coast, where he is attending an international AIDS conference. Gallo, who runs the Institute of Human Virology at the University of Maryland's School of Medicine, told an AP reporter who woke him at home early yesterday that he was "disappointed." He later left for South Africa and could not be reached for further comment, but he released a statement congratulating the French scientists. Colleagues said Gallo was besieged with e-mails and phone calls from scientists around the world, many complaining that an injustice had been done. Dr. Anthony S. Fauci, director of the National Institute for Allergy and Infectious Diseases in Bethesda, said the Nobel Prize tends to be given to those who first identify a new discovery. "I don't think it's a critique of Gallo. It's a statement about the very first observation that is made. This is how they decide," he said. "They generally make their decisions based on what they judge to be the first seminal observation as opposed to what came from that discovery. That's their judgment. "It does not detract from the contributions that Dr. Gallo has made." The Nobel Prize might not put to rest what at times has been a bitter scientific feud spanning two continents. And Gallo, while seen yesterday in some circles as a victim, has often been a less than sympathetic character, seen as abrasive and self-promoting. In the early 1980s, Gallo, whose research at NCI had focused on cancer-causing retroviruses, and Montagnier, at the Pasteur Institute in Paris, were each working on isolating the AIDS virus. In 1983, Montagnier identified a virus he called LAV but was unable to prove it caused AIDS. Gallo, nearly a year later, published a paper on his virus, called HTLV-3, establishing that it caused AIDS. Gallo is credited with being the first to grow the virus in a lab, which paved the way for HIV testing and the screening of donated blood. But a controversy erupted soon after Gallo's publication. There were allegations that Gallo's virus was actually Montagnier's and that he had improperly used it without credit to the Frenchman for first isolating the virus. The dispute triggered investigations by the National Institutes of Health and by Congress. There was a lawsuit. It was finally settled in 1987 by a highly unusual agreement between the United States and France, with a joint announcement by President Ronald Reagan and Prime Minister Jacques Chirac. "I was on the original committee that examined the evidence against Gallo," said Edmund Tramont, who now directs the NIAID's division of AIDS. "We examined all the data and came to the unequivocal conclusion that he did all the work on his own. And that what he discovered and what he wrote, that HIV is a retrovirus that infects T-cells, that it was the cause of AIDS was unequivocal. "He had in his lab previous work that was necessary to isolate the virus and others followed in his footsteps and duplicated what he had done." 今年的诺贝尔物理奖授予了三位日本(裔)物理学家:美国芝加哥大学费米实验室名誉教授南部阳一郎、日本筑波高能加速器研究机构名誉教授小林诚和日本京都大学汤川理论物理研究所名誉教授益川敏英。这也给了中国科学家当头一棒,我们中国现在不是已是培养博士的世界第一了吗,都超越了美国了,而且,在美国获得博士的人中以中国学生居多。为什么中国人离注重科学原创的诺贝尔奖遥遥无期呢!?至此,日本已经有15名诺贝尔奖获得者,而中国依然是空白。我们中国的科学家们脸红不红呢..... 2008 年度诺贝尔化学奖授予美国日裔科学家下村修(Osamu Shimomura)、美国科学家马丁·查尔菲(Martin Chalfie),以及美国华裔科学家钱永健。他们三人在发现和研究绿色荧光蛋白(GFP)方面有突出成就。来自美国海洋生物实验室的下村修和哥伦比亚大学的马丁·查尔菲分别出生于1928年和1947年。 美国华裔钱永健教授1952年出生于纽约,现为美国科学院院士、医学院院士双院士,加州大学圣迭戈分校化学及药理学两系教授,是中国著名科学家钱学森的堂侄。他发明多色莹光蛋白标记技术,为细胞生物学和神经生物学发展带来一场革命。 钱永健教授的获奖是这几年科学界和媒体都看好的事情。饶毅教授已预测了钱永健会得诺贝尔化学奖,美国Thomson Reuters及英国博彩网站立博率先预测结果和开出赔率也预测了钱永健会得诺贝尔化学奖。在化学和生物学界,提起钱永健这个名字,许多不熟悉中文的人,都会觉得陌生,但是提到罗杰钱(Roger Tsien),就无人不知,无人不晓了。他在神经生物学,细胞生物学和化学生物学上的贡献,使得他年年都是诺贝尔化学奖或医学奖的热门人选,今年终于花落钱家,又一次让中国人感到欣慰。 钱永健1952年出生于纽约,后来全家搬到与纽 约相距不远的新泽西州李文斯顿,在那里上学长成。钱家的家谱,似乎就是一本工程师的花名册。他的舅父,曾是麻省理工学院教授,他的堂叔,则是中国导弹之父,大名鼎鼎的钱学森,由此让人不得不相信,聪明也是遗传的。 钱永健年少时患有哮喘病,课余时间不能像兄长那样在外面跑来跑去,很多时间只能呆在室内。十六岁那一年,他以研究金属与硫氰化合物结合方式的论文,获得西屋天才少年科学奖的第一名,并得到全国荣誉奖学金进哈佛大学主修化学和物理。二十岁自哈佛毕业,钱永健得到了马歇尔奖学金,像他的哥哥钱永佑一样,飘洋过海,来到剑桥大学生理系跟随阿德然教授读博士。阿德然教授是世界著名的肌肉电生理学教授,也是一位世袭的伯爵,真正的英格兰绅士,他知道钱永健的潜力,他也知道钱永健的兴趣是在神经生物学方面,于是,经过一番摸索,钱永健充分应用他的化学特长,发明了钙染料技术,可以直接标记观察活体细胞内钙离子信号的流动和变化,为活体细胞内心好传导和功能研究,随后,他又通过遗传工程的方法,发明了多色莹光蛋白标记技术,为细胞生物学和神经生物学的发展带来了一场革命。最近几年,他又致力于应用细胞渗透肽的莹光标记技术,来发现观察癌细胞,希望能为癌症的诊断治疗带来一场革命。 翻开钱永健教授在加州大学圣迭戈分校的网页,可以看到他的实验室是拥有20多人由科学家,博士后,博士生和技术人员组成的团队,依染活跃在科学的前沿,发表着Nature-Protocol,Nature-Method, PNAS等著名杂志的原创性文章和Science,Nature-Protocol和Methods in Enzymology 等杂志书籍上的综述性文章。钱永健教授的科研文章不下几百篇,他的科学工作真是不仅多产,更是开创性和革命性的工作。钱教授手下很多学生都成了名校的 Faculty,像来自台湾的Alice Ting博士现在已是MIT化学系的副教授,Zhang Jin博士也是霍普金斯大学神经科学系的助教授。Robert E. Campbell博士是加拿大阿尔伯塔大学的助教授。钱教授最得意的学生恐怕是近年来被麻省理工学院评为顶尖青年科学家之一的王雷,这位来自北大的学子现在是Salk(索克研究所)的助教授,研究工作相当前沿。 每一年的诺贝尔奖获奖名单下来后,中国人只要是关心科学的人不免都感到心凉和无奈!盘望和期待着何时才有中国科学家获奖的一天。其实以海外华人频频获奖的概率和中国巨大的人口基数和智力库来论,中国人获奖真是指日可待的。但是如果看看国内科研的浮夸,虚假和缺少原创的惨酷现状,我们不得不苦笑,中国人获奖的那一天还是需要等待一些年的!
0%(0)
0%(0)
  请给出下列评论的根据和出处: - 总工程师 10/09/08 (521)
    羞辱一下美国 - 4truth4 10/09/08 (486)
      全世界都认为诺奖是最高科学奖,就你不信?  /无内容 - 飘侠 10/09/08 (283)
        米国人拿了奖,我就信。否则不信!就是不信;-)  /无内容 - 卡拉喔呵 10/09/08 (254)
      这儿在谈原创成果,没有政治因素!  /无内容 - 飘侠 10/09/08 (212)
    还没读过维基关于钱的章节呢,估计 - 飘侠 10/09/08 (310)
    说反了,说倒了。 - 上海读者 10/10/08 (376)
  鼎飘侠!  /无内容 - 紫荆棘鸟 10/09/08 (292)
    风马牛不相及,无耻!  /无内容 - yinyue 10/09/08 (269)
  我国还没有真科学研究的土壤! 也许要等几百年不止.  /无内容 - seekerMr 10/09/08 (258)
  好文。 - 风丽 10/08/08 (300)
缂佹鎷� 闁告熬鎷� (闊洤鎳橀埀顒€顦甸妴锟�): 閻庣鎷� 闁活噯鎷� (闊洤鎳橀埀顒€顦甸妴锟�): 婵炲鍔岄崬浠嬪棘閹殿喗鏆忛柟杈炬嫹
标 题 (必选项):
内 容 (选填项):
闂傚倷娴囬褏鈧稈鏅濈划娆撳箳濡も偓妗呴梺缁樺姉閺佸摜绮堟繝鍥ㄧ叆闁绘洖鍊圭€氾拷
闂傚倷娴囬褏鈧稈鏅濈划娆撳箳濡炲皷鍋撻崘顔煎窛闁煎壊鍏涘Ч妤呮⒑鐠恒劌娅愰柟鍑ゆ嫹
实用资讯
回国机票$360起 | 商务舱省$200 | 全球最佳航空公司出炉:海航获五星
海外华人福利!在线看陈建斌《三叉戟》热血归回 豪情筑梦 高清免费看 无地区限制
一周点击热帖 更多>>
1 閻庢稒鐟﹀▍鐐烘晬濮橆剚韬柡鍐勫倸濮涢幖瀛橆殕缁愭劙宕氭0浣哄晩閻庣櫢鎷� 闁兼亽鍔忔慨鈺呮嚒閿燂拷
2 濞戞挸绉磋ぐ鏌ュ箵韫囨艾鐗氶柣銊ュ缁卞墎浜歌箛娑氭嫧闁挎稒鍝庨埀顒€锕ㄩ妶鍨€掑宀婂敹闁靛棗顑呯敮锟� 閻忕偞鐟﹂弸鍐传閿燂拷
3 闊洤鍟粊锔芥償閺団剝娈诲璺哄濠€顏堢叕椤愩垻濡囨繛鍡楀级閻壆鎮伴妸銉х獧闁汇劌瀚崜鎵嫚閿燂拷 闁哄倽顫夐弻锟�
4 闁稿浚鍙€铻濆☉鎾崇Х缁诲酣寮伴姘ヤ海濠靛倹鍨濈花銊╂晬娴gǹ纭€闁规娊顥撻幊銏㈡啺椤忓嫬缍撻悹鈧敓锟� 閻忕偞鐟﹂弸鍐传閿燂拷
5 閺夆晜鐟ら柌婊呬焊鏉堛劍笑濮掓稑瀚槐鎴︽嚄濠婂懏鐣遍柤棰佺閿曗晛顕i悩鍙夊闁革箑妫涘▓鎴犳導閿燂拷 閻忕偞鐟﹂弸鍐传閿燂拷
6 閻犲鐗愮€垫牗绗熺€n剚鐣遍柍銉︾矋濡拷 = 闁告棑鎷� = 闁革负鍔夐埀顒婃嫹 濞戞搩鍘煎ù妤呮偝妫颁礁鏁╅柛婵撴嫹
7 濞寸姭鍋撳☉鏂跨墛濡插摜绮旈幋婵愬妳闁汇劌瀚埀顒佺箖閸忓倿寮憴鍕€� 闁藉倸顑夊鍫ユ煣閿燂拷
8 1996 缂佺嫏鍜佹晪濠㈣鍋嗛悥铏圭矚閸撲焦鏅哥€殿喚濮村〒楣冨捶閸℃凹鍟忛悹瀣舵嫹 閻忕偞鐟﹂弸鍐传閿燂拷
9 濞寸姴绨堕埀顒佺矊閵囧洭鎮ラ崱娆忎划闁告挸绉靛﹢锟犲礆娴煎鎷ㄦ繛鑼亹閳ь剨鎷� 濞戞挸绨肩划鐘诲灳閿燂拷 濞戞搩鍘煎ù妤呮偝妫颁礁鏁╅柛婵撴嫹
10 闁兼剚鍙€閸撴盯濡撮幇顖涘矮闁哄绠栭崑銉╁Υ閹寸姵顏ら悷顓$簿娴滅増顬囩€n偅娅婂ù婊愭嫹 閻忕偞鐟﹂弸鍐传閿燂拷
一周回复热帖
1 闁稿繐鍘栫花顒勫炊娴犲顎庨柛蹇氭珪閺佺偤鎯岄妷銊ф濞存籂鍕秬闁告绻嬬槐浼村Υ閹邦厾鍨� 闁绘粌顑囩敮鈧柤鐚存嫹
2 濠㈠爢鍥紪濡増銈alectic闁挎稒鑹鹃々褎鎷呴弴锛勬闁哄嫬姘︾换鏍ㄧ▔閿燂拷 閻忕偞鐟﹂弸鍐传閿燂拷
3 閺夆晜鐟﹂悧閬嶆儍閸曨亝鐪界憸鐗堟尫閼垫垿宕楁潏鈺傜暠闁轰焦鐟ㄩ崑娑㈡焾閵娾晜姣愰柤铏灊鐠愮喐绋夐敓锟� 閻熸洖鎳撻々锟�
4 婵烇絻鍔庨埞鏍嚀娴e湱銆婇悽顖ゆ嫹:婵烇絻鍔屽﹢鈩冨緞瑜忕粙澶岀矓閹达缉鎴︽晬閸埄鍎戦柛銉嫹 濞存粣绠戦悿鈧柣鎺炴嫹
5 闁诡儸鍕嫳闁哥姴瀚ч埀顒佹煛閳ь剚姊归崹婊呪偓鐢垫嚀閺変粙鎯冮崟顒佹殘閻熸瑱楗ラ柨瀣亯闁告粌鐡昬 闁哄倽顫夐弻锟�
6 濠㈤浜Σ鑲╁寲婵犳艾娅ら悗娑欏姇婵繒鈧冻濡囩划銊╁几閸曨偅鍣柡鍫㈠枙閵嗗啴鏁嶉崼婊咁吅濞存粣鎷� 濞存粍鏌ㄥ畷鍕嚃閿燂拷
7 闁哄瀛╁ḿ顔硷耿濠婂棌鍋撻崘顓燁€氶柛娆愬灱閹癸綁骞嬮幇顔惧綄濞戞搩鍘煎ù妤呭炊閵忋垻娉㈤弶鈺嬫嫹 闁绘粌顑囩敮鈧柤鐚存嫹
8 濠㈤浜Σ鑲╁寲婵犳艾娅ら悗娑欏姇婵繒鈧冻濡囩划銊╁几閸曨偅鍣柡鍫㈠枙閵嗗啴鏁嶉崼婊咁吅濞存粣鎷� 濞存粍鏌ㄥ畷鍕嚃閿燂拷
9 闁靛棗锕ら妵鍥触鐏炵瓔鍚呴悷灏佸亾闁靛棗顑冮埀顒佸姈閻栵綁宕欓崱娆忣暭闁哄牜鍏欓埀顒婃嫹 闁绘粌顑囩敮鈧柤鐚存嫹
10 闁哄閰e▍鎺楁儗閻愯В鍋撴繝鍌樹海闁告艾鑻铏规嚊閳ь剟濡寸€n偆啸闁诡収鍨遍悥鏌ユ偋閸喐鎷� 闁绘粌顑囩敮鈧柤鐚存嫹
历史上的今天:回复热帖
2005: 评唐十七关于北大事实真相之诡辩
2005: 洪家兴: 还我一片安宁
2004: 稳恒宇宙和更为精确的宇宙微波背景辐射
2004: 关于夸克和伯根斯坦熵限再讲几句
2003: 诺贝尔奖的美元金额在增加,学术含金量
2003: 我所知道的2003年诺贝尔物理奖得主阿列

闂傚倸鍊搁崐鐑芥嚄閼哥數浠氱紓鍌欒兌缁垶宕濆▎蹇曟殾闁靛繈鍊曢崘鈧銈嗗姂閸庡崬鐨┑锛勫亼閸婃牜鏁幒鏂哄亾濮樼厧澧伴柍褜鍓氶懝楣兯囨导鏉懳﹂柛鏇ㄥ灠缁犳娊鏌熺€涙ḿ濡囬柛瀣崌瀵媽绠涚€b晜鐫忛梻浣芥硶閸o箓骞忛敓锟� | 濠电姴鐥夐弶搴撳亾濡や焦鍙忛柣鎴f绾剧粯绻涢幋娆忕仾闁稿﹨鍩栫换婵嬫濞戝崬鍓扮紓浣哄Х閸犳牠寮婚妸鈺傚亜闁告繂瀚呴姀銈嗗€垫慨姗嗗墻濡叉椽鏌嶈閸撴瑧绮诲澶婄?闂侇剙绉寸粻鐘诲箹閹碱厾鍘滅紓宥嗙墵閺屻劑鎮ら崒娑橆伓 | 闂傚倸鍊搁崐宄懊归崶銊х彾闁割偆鍠嗘禒鍫㈢磼鐎n偒鍎ユ繛鍏肩墪閳规垿鎮╁畷鍥舵殹闂佺粯甯$粻鏍蓟閻旇櫣纾奸柕蹇曞У閻忓牏绱撴担鍝勵€撶紓宥勭窔瀵鎮㈢悰鈥充壕婵炴垶鐟$紓姘舵煟椤撶儐鍎戠紒杈ㄥ浮椤㈡岸宕卞Ο渚紦 | 闂傚倸鍊搁崐椋庣矆娴h櫣绀婂┑鐘叉搐缂佲晠寮堕崼姘珖闁活厽鐟╅弻鈥愁吋閸愩劌顬嬪銈傛櫇閸忔﹢寮婚悢鍏煎€绘俊顖濐嚙閺嗘姊哄畷鍥ㄥ殌缂佸缍婂璇差吋婢跺﹦鍘告繛杈剧到閹测€斥枔閵娧呯=濞达絿鎳撻弫楣冩煙閸戙倖瀚� | 缂傚倸鍊搁崐鎼佸磹閹间礁纾归柟闂寸閻ゎ喗銇勯弽顐粶闁搞劌鍊婚幉鎼佹偋閸繄鐟查梺绋款儑閸犳劙濡甸崟顖氬唨闁靛ǹ鍎哄Λ婊堟⒑缁嬫鍎愰柟绋款煼楠炲繘宕ㄩ弶鎴狀槰濡炪値鍘介崹鍫曀夊澶嬧拻濞达綀娅i妴濠囨煛閸滀椒閭鐐茬箻閺佹捇鏁撻敓锟� | 闂傚倸鍊搁崐鎼佸磹閹间礁纾归柟闂寸缁犵娀鐓崶銊р槈缂佲偓婢跺绻嗛柕鍫濇噺鐎氬懐绱撳鍡欏⒌闁哄本鐩崺鍕礃閿涘嫮绐楅梻浣哥-閹虫挾绮旈悽鍨床婵犻潧顑嗛ˉ鍫熺箾閹寸偟鎳勯柟顔界懇閹泛顫濋悙顒€顏�

Copyright (C) 1998-2025. Creaders.NET. All Rights Reserved.