印度海外高管 印度沒有榮譽 合同 友誼 尊嚴的概念

如果你讓我搬到中國生活，我會非常非常高興。如果讓我搬到印度，我開槍自殺。

印度的水管工，一旦我離開，他們就會再給我製造出三個問題，甚至五個新問題。

YouTube

賈楊特班達裏海外高印：講述他眼中的印度和中國的區別 Jayant Bhandari： What is the difference between India and China?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZ0lIeijlGY&t=85s

你好，大衛，謝謝你再次邀請我，當然，你現在是節目的朋友了，每次我提到你，每個人都會說，請把他帶回來，我總是向社區保證，我會帶你回來，然後通常你會經常環遊世界。

我總是告訴他們，嘿，這取決於他的日程安排，當他有空時，他會告訴我，通常我們會這樣做，所以無論如何，非常非常高興你能來這裡，因為我喜歡得到你的反饋意見和見解分析，無論你想用什麼術語來描述印度最近的選舉結果，在我看來，這些選舉已經動搖了這個國家的發展軌跡，這個國家是地球上人口最多的國家，但現在我們將看到一些不同的東西。

我想首先問的問題是，誰將現在控制莫迪，因為他的政黨沒有多數席位，首先，大衛，我不認為印度的發展軌跡因為這次選舉而改變，嗯，印度正在分崩離析印度不斷陷入危機模式，自從英國人離開印度以來，這種情況就一直在持續，所以印度在過去的 76 年裡一直在走向衰落，所以這些都是選舉結果的小問題，但事實是印度正在分崩離析，情況一天比一天糟糕，誰來控制這個國家並不重要，莫迪，我一點都不喜歡他，但他只是這個國家文化問題的一個表現，現在人們通常會問我，他不是多數派，這對這個國家有什麼影響？

你真的必須了解，印度社會和聯合國文化的基礎是，印度沒有榮譽的概念，沒有合同的概念，沒有友誼的概念，沒有個性的概念，沒有尊重你所同意的東西的概念，所以你的朋友和家人其實就是你最大的敵人，哇，這就是為什麼人們會把黃金藏在地下而不告訴自己的家人，他們在房子周圍築起高高的圍牆，因為如果你不這樣做，鄰居就會在一夜之間把籬笆移走。

所以你必須明白，這是一個沒有榮譽的國家，這是一個你絕對不能信任任何人的國家，你最親近的人是你最大的敵人，那麼人民呢，那麼印度人民呢，我的意思是，我認識一些印度人，你知道他們受過教育，但他們沒有就業機會，因為政府沒有創造這些，政府沒有照顧基礎設施等等，所以人民發生了什麼，政府不應該在那裡嗎？

在這種情況下，莫迪已經執政二十多年了，差不多二十年了，確切地說是14年，他在經濟上取得了什麼成就，我們可以談論他什麼也做不了。

大衛，我通常喜歡在印度，兩個人組成的組織中，一個人太多了，人們無法組織起來，人們無法相互信任。

如果我需要舊金山的水管工，我會叫人來幫我修理，如果我需要印度的水管工，我可能只需要付給他幾美元就可以完成我的工作，但他會在我離開之前再給我製造三個問題，甚至五個新問題，所以我最好自己在印度做我的水管工作，這就是我實際上所做的。

所以問題是，印度人要對他們的現狀負責，這就是為什麼我總是說，莫迪只是問題的一個症狀，莫迪不是這個國家的問題，也不是這個國家的解決方案，這個問題的根本問題是印度，印度人是非理性的，他們沒有道德結構，他們沒有榮譽制度，這就是為什麼印度將繼續衰落，無論哪個政黨在該國執政。

西方分析人士卻說，印度的經濟將會成為事實上的，我聽到一些西方智庫說，印度的經濟將被視為世界第三，我想，等等，你們是從哪裡得出這些聲明的，甚至我們的一位觀眾，在這個頻道里，他的名字是 Connie Lee 9678，他寫道，我在這裡引用 David 博士的話，印度政府在過去幾年中一直聲稱其 GDP 增長高於任何其他國家，有什麼方法可以驗證他們的數字的計算，這聽起來有點可疑，引用結束，你怎麼看？好吧，這沒關係。

David，即使你認為印度的 GDP 增長率是 10%，讓我們假設出於數學目的，將人均 GDP 為 2,500 美元的國家的 GDP 增長率與人均 GDP 為 60,000 美元的國家進行比較是錯誤的，因此，如果人均 GDP 為 60,000 美元的美國如果印度的人均GDP增長1%，那麼印度的人均GDP每年將增加600美元，而如果印度的人均GDP增長10%，那麼印度的人均GDP只會增加250美元，這意味着印度的增長速度仍將是美國的一半，但其GDP增長的百分比相對來說並不顯著。

大衛，問題是，我們在中學時就學到了這一點，除非基線相似，否則你無法比較百分比，你無法比較老鼠的增長率和大象的增長率，這就是這些大經濟學家所犯的錯誤，他們中的許多人實際上都是空談，他們真的很幼稚，在文化上是文盲。

他們並不真正理解世界各地的人之間存在差異，宗教是不同的文化是不同的，他們只是看圖表，認為每個國家最終都會像中國或韓國那樣消亡，我的意思是我甚至在某處讀到過，它說印度經濟將超過印度要超越中國，我當時想，這太荒謬了。

24 小時前，我在中國，大衛，我在中國呆了很長時間，我們通過香港證券交易所在中國投資，我愛中國，中國和印度根本無法比較，如果你想讓我搬到中國，在那裡生活，我會非常非常高興地這樣做，我在中國得到自由，在中國得到便利、舒適和設施，如果你想讓我搬到印度生活，我會開槍自殺。

這就是兩個國家的不同之處，你甚至不應該把印度和中國進行比較，中國是一個理智的國家，中國是一個理性的國家，你可以在中國過上體面的生活。

但是，在印度，你無法過上體面的生活，我想毫不誇張地說。

大衛，印度人的生活就像你一到印度就看到的那樣，一切都很混亂，人們在那個國家並沒有真正過上理智、有尊嚴的生活。

hello David thanks for having me again
of course of course you are now friend
of the show anytime I mention you
everybody is like please bring him back
in and I always promise the community
that I am gonna be bringing you and then
usually you travel around the world a
lot and I always tell them hey that
depends on his schedule when he's
available he'll let me know and usually
we do it so anyway very very excited to
have you here because I like to get your
feedback inputs and uh insights analysis
whatever term you want to use about the
recent outcome elections in India now
those elections in my opinion have
shaken the
trajectory now for the country which is
the mo most populous nation on Earth
here except now we're gonna be seeing
something different and the question I
would like to start with is who's going
to be controlling Modi right now since
his party doesn't have majority
well firstly David I don't think the
trajectory of India has changed because
of this election um India was falling
apart India was going into a crisis mode
continuously and it that has been going
on for since the time the British left
the country so India has been on a path
to degradation for the last 76 years so
these are small hiccups about the the
outcome of Elections but the fact
remains that India is falling apart it's
getting worse by the day and it does not
matter who controls the the country Modi
is uh is I don't like him at all but
he's just a symptom of the underpinning
cultural problem to do with the
country uh now people usually ask me how
does uh he not being in majority matter
to the
country you really have to understand
one culture cult Al underpinning of
Indian society and the UN cultural
underpinning is that India has no
concept of
Honor there's no concept of contracts
there's no concept of friendship there's
no concept of um individuality and
respect for what you agree with so your
friends and families are your actually
biggest
enemies wow that is why people hide gold
in in the ground without telling their
own family members and they erect huge
High walls around their houses because
if you don't then the neighbor will
shift the fence overnight so you have to
understand that this is a country
without honor this is a country where
you can trust absolutely no one and the
people closest to you are your biggest
enemies what about the people what about
the Indian people I mean I know some
people in India that you know they are
educated but they have no no sort of
opportunities for employment because the
government is not creating this the
government is not sort of taking care of
infrastructure and so forth so what
happened to the people isn't the
government supposed there to sort of
Modi in this case he's been in power
over two decade almost two decades now
14 years to be exact what has he
achieved economically speaking that we
can talk about
well he cannot achieve anything David I
usually like to say that in an
organization of two people in India
there's one person too many people can't
organize in that country people can't
trust each other in that country um and
people are completely unscaled if I need
a plumber in San Francisco I call
someone in to do my repair job if I need
a in India I might need to pay him only
a couple of dollars to do my job but he
will create three more problems or maybe
five more new problems for me before he
leaves so I'm better off doing my
plumbing job myself in India and that is
what I actually do so uh the problem is
that Indians are responsible for their
status quo and that is why I always say
that Modi is just a symptom of the
problem Modi is not the problem of the
country neither is Modi the solution of
the of the countryes this problem the
cold problem is India Indians are
irrational and they don't have the moral
fabric they don't have the honor System
and that is why India will continue to
degrade irrespective of which party is
in power in that
country and yet Western analysts are
saying well the economy of India is
going to sort of be as a matter of fact
I heard some Western think tanks saying
that that the economy of India it will
be considered like the third in the
world and I was like hold on second
where are you guys coming up with these
statements from and even one of our
viewers uh uh in in the channel here uh
wrote his name is Connie Lee 9678 he
wrote and I quote here Dr David the
Indian government has been claiming for
each of the last few years that its GDP
growth is higher than any that is higher
than that of every other country what
would be a way of verifying the calcul
of their figure which sound a bit
dubious end of quote what do you what do
you think J well it doesn't matter U
David even if you consider Indian GDP
growth to be 10% and let's assume that
for mathematical purpose to be 10% it is
erroneous to compare GDP growth of a
country with GDP per capita of
$2,500 with a country whose GDP per cap
cap might be $60,000 so if the United
States with $60,000 per capita GDP grows
at 1% it adds $600 per year to its per
capita GDP whereas if India adds 10% to
its per capita GDP it only adds $250 to
its per capita GDP which means that
India would still be growing at half as
much Pace as the US would be growing
with its much as
relatively insignificant percentage wise
um GDP growth the issue is David and we
learned this in the middle school that
you cannot compare percentage with
percentages unless the Baseline is
similar you can't compare the growth
rate of a mouse with a growth rate of an
elephant and that is what the error
these big economists do a lot of them
are actually empty suits and they really
are naive and illiterate on cultural
basis they don't really understand that
there's a difference between people
around the world the religions are
different cultures are different they
just look at graphs and think that every
country would eventually follow the way
China or South Korea dead I mean I even
read somewhere where it says that it's
gonna
overtake the Indian econom is gonna
overtake that of China I was like what
well it's ridiculous so so 24 hours back
I was in China David I spent a lot of
time in China we invest in China through
the Hong Kong Stock Exchange um I love
China China and India are not comparable
at all if you wanted me to move to China
and live there I would very very happily
do so I I get freedom in China I get
conveniences comfort and facilities in
China if you wanted me to move to live
in India I will shoot myself that is how
different the two countries are um the
you should not even be comparing India
with China China is a sane country China
is a rational country uh you can have a
decent existence in China you cannot
have a decent existence in India I like
to say David without any exaggeration
that Indians live lives of they live and
die like that's what you see the moment
you land in India things are chaotic
people don't really have a
sane dignified existence in that country