. ------------------ -------------------Manu-----Kobe
1 score ability------------------------9---------9
2 pass---------------------------------10--------4
3 defense------------------------------9--------10
4 clinch performance ------------------10-------10
5 make team and teammate better--------10--------2
6 Exciting to watch--------------------10-------10
7 Carry a team to win------------------10--------7
8 Total--------------------------------68-------52
9 % as a perfect player----------------97.14%---74.28%

1. Kobe’s score ability is slightly reduced by his relatively low efficiency
2. Kobe is no where even close to Manu. Actually Manu’s pass ability is so ahead of others in NBA he might be reduce a few points because sometimes his teammate could not realize his seemly impossible pass.
3. Defense is all about effort. Both have no problem. Manu is reduced one point for his tendency to take opportunity for steal, which occasionally leaves his man wide open.
4. can hardly find a third one in NBA to match these two.
5. as a notorious chemistry destroyer and black hole, Kobe narrowly missed negative point in this column by his score ability that sometimes helps.
7. considering poor record of last year’s Laker, 7 is probably too high for Kobe.
9. a perfect player scores 70.