Alan Greenspan Was Right! (About Antitrust, Anyway)
https://mises.org/library/alan-greenspan-was-right-about-antitrust-anyway
The world of antitrust is reminiscent of Alice's
Wonder-land: everything seemingly is, yet apparently isn't,
simultaneously. It is a world in which competition is lauded as the
basic axiom and guiding principle, yet "too much" competition is
condemned as "cutthroat." It is a world in which actions designed to
limit competition are branded as criminal when taken by businessmen, yet
praised as "enlightened" when initiated by the government. It is a
world in which the law is so vague that businessmen have no way of
knowing whether specific actions will be declared illegal until they
hear the judge's verdict — after the fact. (Alan Greenspan, "Antitrust,"
in Ayn Rand, ed., Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal, 1962)
Greenspan was also right when he concluded in the same essay that
"the entire structure of antitrust statutes in this country is a jumble
of economic irrationality and ignorance" and is the product of "a gross
misrepresentation of history, and of rather naïve, and certainly
unrealistic, economic theories."
In Power and Market Murray Rothbard pointed out
that almost the entire economics profession has aided and abetted this
"irrationality and ignorance" by constructing a theoretical apparatus
(the "perfect-competition" model and myriad theories of "imperfect"
competition) that has long served as an intellectual "justification" for
one of the most destructive forms of economic interventionism.
Only the Austrian School, with a much more intellectually rigorous
understanding of competition and monopoly, has provided consistent
opposition to the destructiveness of antitrust regulation. The Austrian
economists' theories of competition and entrepreneurship have always
been at the heart of their contributions to all economic
debates (not just the antitrust debate), from the famous
socialist-calculation debate of the early 20th century to criticisms of
central banking as just another cartel, to government regulation of
industry in general, and many other issues. The Austrian theory of
competition as a dynamic, rivalrous process of entrepreneurship and
discovery — as opposed to a set of static mathematical equilibrium
conditions (as with the "mainstream" theory) — is a cornerstone of the
Austrian School of economics.