設萬維讀者為首頁 廣告服務 聯繫我們 關於萬維
簡體 繁體 手機版
分類廣告
版主:丁丁家長
萬維讀者網 > 海 二 代 > 帖子
On Granger causality
送交者: jingchen 2024年04月21日06:20:48 於 [海 二 代] 發送悄悄話

On Granger causality

 

Many years ago, I learned the concept of Granger causality. How can a statistical test determine causality? I wondered.

 

Recently, I learned that Granger causality is not a causality. In the words of Granger himself, 

 

It is doubtful that philosophers would completely accept this definition, and possibly cause is too strong a term, or one too emotionally laden, to be used. A better term might be temporally related, but since cause is such a simple term we shall continue to use it. (Granger and Newbold, 1977, p 225)

 

Granger causality is really temporally related, not causality. But the term causality makes the research findings more prominent and makes the researchers themselves more prominent. Causality implies many policy implications littered in research papers. This term becomes extremely popular over time.

 

In general, an idea becomes popular not because it promotes truth, but because it promotes the advocates of the idea. This is the case in any human activities, including science.

 

Reference

 

Granger, C. W. J.; Newbold, Paul (1977). Forecasting Economic Time Series. New York: Academic Press. p. 225

 


0%(0)
0%(0)
標 題 (必選項):
內 容 (選填項):
實用資訊
回國機票$360起 | 商務艙省$200 | 全球最佳航空公司出爐:海航獲五星
海外華人福利!在線看陳建斌《三叉戟》熱血歸回 豪情築夢 高清免費看 無地區限制
一周點擊熱帖 更多>>
一周回復熱帖
歷史上的今天:回復熱帖
2021: ★轉:小寶和小貝春天遊玩在加拿大多倫
2020: 如何激發華裔少兒學生的中文學習興趣