近來,有心人作了一個統計來觀察那些美國的頂尖大學裡計算機系悄悄發生的變化。簡單的結果反映了不少值得注意的趨勢。有志來美深造的同胞可能會有興趣。特抄錄於此。共參考。
計算機(CS)牛校最近幾年招的教授(faculty)的來源分析
前兩天剛剛完成一個統計,就是全美前10名的計算機系助理教授(Assistant Professor)的Ph.D.出身。
因為這在很大程度上代表了CS牛校過去幾年招的faculty的來源。
計算機系規模(faculty人數, 排除兼職,退休及其他研究人員):
CMU CS: 100+
MIT CS: 70-
Berkeley CS: 55
Stanford CS: 42
UIUC CS: 50+
Cornell CS: 40+
Princeton CS: 30+
UW Madison CS: 40-
Washington-Seattle CS: 45
UT Austin: 42
Caltech CS: 10+
UIUC的計算機系規模大得嚇人,50+個faculty, 24個Assistant Prof.
CMU是一個School of CS,規模自然最大,100+個faculty, 17個Assistant Prof.
Cornell最近幾年似乎faculty招得不少,13個Assistant Prof.
其餘學校,MIT是12個Assistant Prof,已經是最多的了。
Berkeley只有6個,除了Caltech 4個之外是最少的。
在CS專業內,如果你將來想在學術界發展,UIUC的表現so-so.
UIUC如此巨大之規模,在top10學校差不多100個新faculty裡面,只有2個Ph.D
(此外,Cornell ECE新faculty裡面,有2個UIUC CS 的Ph.D).
Berkeley 18個Ph.D.,MIT 17個Ph.D.,最為領先。
尤其是Berkeley,過去十年其Grad School扶搖直上,實際上已經超過MIT。
MIT招了3個自己的Ph.D.當faculty,Berkeley就體面多了,只招了1個。
所以,算在外校當faculty的Ph.D.,Berkeley 17:14壓倒MIT。
接下來,Stanford.,Cornell和CMU各有10個Ph.D,構成第二集團。
但是如果有offer,我個人認為Stanford還是更好一些,從學術聲譽上說。
其它的top10學校就不那麼突出了,最好的UW-Madison也就5個Ph.D.
主要是因為UW-Madison的數據庫和體繫結構都是全美最強,5個faculty全部出自於此。
Caltech雖然規模很小,也有3個Ph.D.,但是規模小意味着選擇範圍小。
Caltech的聲譽固然頂尖,但是從學術角度考慮,前5名的學校應該比Caltech更好。
U Washington也有3個Ph.D.,但是含金量顯然不如Caltech.
UIUC有2個Ph.D.,Princeton有1個Ph.D.,UT Austin光頭。
Note 1: many CS PhD's join EE departments as faculty, and vice versa.
Also, some assistant professors just become associate professors this
year, some old PhDs were in industry and just become assistant
professors this year.
Note 2: every school is different. Some schools prefer to hire old
established big guys, some others prefer to hire young productive
guys.
The recent computer science hires (assistant professors) of top universities:
MIT: (12)
Regina Barzilay, PhD Columbia
Michael Collins, PhD UPENN
Erik Demaine, PhD U of Waterloo (Canada)
Frédo Durand, PhD U of Grenoble (France)
Michael D. Ernst, PhD Washington (Seattle)
Polina Golland, PhD MIT
Dina Katabi, PhD MIT
Manolis Kellis, PhD MIT
Samuel Madden, PhD Berkeley
Robert C. Miller, PhD CMU
Jovan Popovic, PhD CMU
Vladimir Stojanovic, PhD Stanford
Stanford: (9)
Serafim Batzoglou, PhD MIT
Dawson Engler, PhD MIT
Ron Fedkiw, PhD UCLA
Armando Fox, PhD Berkeley
Scott Klemmer, PhD Berkeley
Christoforos Kozyrakis, PhD Berkeley
Chris Manning, PhD Stanford
Andrew Ng, PhD Berkeley
Tim Roughgarden, PhD Cornell
Berkeley: (6)
Ras Bodik, PhD Pittsburgh
Dan Klein, PhD Stanford
Jennifer Mankoff, PhD Georgia Tech
James F. O'Brien, PhD Georgia Tech
Ion Stoica, Carnegie Mellon
David Wagner, PhD Berkeley
CMU: (17)
Anastassia Ailamaki, PhD UW Madison
Jonathan Aldrich, PhD Washington (Seattle)
Ziv Bar-Joseph, PhD MIT
Karl Crary, PhD Cornell
Alexei (Alyosha) Efros, PhD Berkeley
Carlos Guestrin, PhD Stanford
Anupam Gupta, PhD Berkeley
Doug James, PhD U of British Columbia (Canada)
Christopher James Langmead, PhD Dartmouth
Mor Harchol-Balter, PhD Berkeley
Michael Lewicki, PhD Caltech
Jennifer Mankoff, PhD Georgia Tech
Yoky Matsuoka, PhD MIT
Nancy Pollard, PhD MIT
Latanya Sweeney, PhD MIT
Eric P Xing, PhD Berkeley
John Zimmerman, PhD
UIUC: (24)
Vikram Adve, PhD UW Madison
Eyal Amir, PhD Stanford
Brian Bailey, PhD Minnesota
Stephen Bond, PhD Kansas
Marco Caccamo, PhD Scuola Superiore S. Anna (Italy)
Kevin Chang, PhD Stanford
Eric de Sturler, PhD Delft (Holland)
AnHai Doan, Washington (Seattle)
Michael Garland, PhD CMU
Indranil Gupta, PhD Cornell
Sariel Har-Peled, PhD Tel-Aviv (Isael)
Anil Hirani, PhD Caltech
Karrie Karahalios, PhD MIT
Robin Kravets, PhD Georgia Tech
Haiyun Luo, PhD UCLA
Darko Marinov, PhD MIT
Madhusudan Parthasarathy, PhD University of Madras (India)
Edgar Ramos, PhD UIUC
Grigore Rosu, PhD UCSD
Mahesh Viswanathan, PhD UPENN
Yizhou Yu, PhD Berkeley
ChengXiang Zhai, PhD CMU
Yuanyuan Zhou, PhD Princeton
Craig Zilles, PhD UW Madison
Cornell: (13)
Kavita Bala, PhD MIT
Rich Caruana, PhD Carnegie Mellon
K-Y. Daisy Fan, PhD Cornell
Johannes Gehrke, PhD UW-Madison
Thorsten Joachims, PhD U of Dortmund
Uri Keich, PhD NYU
Steve Marschner, PhD Cornell
Andrew Myers, PhD MIT
Radu Rugina, PhD UCSB
David Schwartz, PhD SUNY Buffalo
Jayavel Shanmugasundaram, PhD UW-Madison
E. Gun Sirer, PhD U of Washington
Golan Yona, PhD Hebrew U
Princeton: (8)
David August, PhD UIUC
Moses Charikar, PhD Stanford
Vivek Pai, PhD Rice
Szymon Rusinkiewicz, PhD Stanford
Mona Singh, PhD MIT
Olga Troyanskaya, PhD Stanford
David Walker, PhD Cornell
Randy Wang, PhD Berkeley
U of Washington: (6)
Dieter Fox, PhD University of Bonn
Steven D. Gribble, PhD Berkeley
Dan Grossman, PhD Cornell
Venkatesan Guruswami, PhD MIT
Mark Oskin, PhD UC Davis
Rajesh P. N. Rao, PhD Rochester
UT-Austin: (9)
William R. Cook, PhD Brown
Inderjit S. Dhillon, PhD Berkeley
Adam Klivans, PhD MIT
William (Bill) Mark, PhD UNC
Lili Qiu, PhD Cornell
Vitaly Shmatikov, PhD Stanford
Peter Stone, PhD Carnegie Mellon
Emmett Witchel, PhD MIT
Yin Zhang, PhD Cornell
UW-Madison: (9)
Andrea Arpaci-Dusseau, PhD Berkeley
Remzi Arpaci-Dusseau, PhD Berkeley
Suman Banerjee, PhD Maryland
Paul Barford, PhD Boston University
Stephen Chenney, PhD Berkeley
Cristian Estan, PhD UCSD
Somesh Jha, PhD CMU
Ben Liblit, PhD Berkeley
Dieter van Melkebeek, PhD Chicago
Caltech: (4)
Andr?DeHon, PhD MIT
Jason Hickey, PhD Cornell
Chris Umans, PhD Berkeley
Erik Winfree, PhD Caltech
---------------------------------------------------------------
此外,
Harvard: (4)
David Brooks, PhD Princeton
David C. Parkes, PhD UPenn
Mema Roussopoulos, PhD Stanford
Matt Welsh, PhD Berkeley
Yale: (4)
Arvind Krishnamurthy, PhD Berkeley
Brian Scassellati, PhD MIT
Carsten Schoemann, PhD Carnegie Mellon
Yang Richard Yang, PhD UT-Austin