投稿PRL最終感言:這次投稿經歷讓我深深感覺到:比起屋艾斯阿的偽民主,咱們中國要民主多了。
Dear Prof. Sandweiss and Prof. Sprouse,
please accept this letter as our formal appeal to an editorial decision (14 October 2011) to reject our paper (LF13494). This decision was made based on the report from one of the Divisional Associate Editor (DAE).
...
In conclusion, we feel that the DAE made a decision hastily based on two problems we have well solved, and we hope you can consider our paper on a FAIR standpoint. If your decision is still to reject, we would feel very disappointed, and we hope that our paper can be accepted by PRA or PRB without further review.
Best Regards,
Lianyi He and Xu-Guang Huang
http://blog.sciencenet.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=291838&do=blog&id=497324