so far, there is no conclusion |
送交者: Yuehanmiao 2008月11月14日06:13:02 于 [彩虹之约] 发送悄悄话 |
回 答: 哈哈哈哈,老苗这贴绝了,还真是,我看这驴叫式方言 由 candle 于 2008-11-13 19:57:38 |
about 方言,
1. a language somebody is using and/or 2. a language nobody knows concerning group 1, clear, concerning group 2, it is possible like the case involved with BaLan, he acted as an interpreter to himself, from 'ahh-o-ahh' into 'U-turn', he also acted as a speaker to Israel, he maybe said 'go to the hell, Yi3Se4Lie4 people', but Israelite heard of 'God be with you, Yi3Se4Lie4 people, don't be afraid, victory is waiting for you' therefore, what I can say now is that we have nothing at hand to exclude 方言 like group 2, although it is obviously everybody is capable to create 方言 like group 2 in fact, as I mentioned before, a group of people (using King James Bible and calling themselves The Way) taught everybody should speak 方言 and everybody could speak 方言, a gentleman even taught me HOW to speak 方言, of course, I can speak that kind of 方言 like they do, the only question to me is why I should speak that kind of 方言. Thus, that kind of 方言 should not be classified as group 2. |
|
|
|
实用资讯 | |
|
|
一周点击热帖 | 更多>> |
|
|
一周回复热帖 |
|
历史上的今天:回复热帖 |
2007: | 危机与转机 (三十二) | |
2007: | 我感觉 | |
2006: | 现今教会的问题 | |
2006: | 灵恩的问题 (三)关于灵恩问题辩论的 | |
2005: | 九十九只羊:半杯水 | |
2005: | 心愿 | |
2004: | 萍水萍水总相逢(2) | |
2004: | 木林zt: 语言与生俱来 | |