設萬維讀者為首頁 廣告服務 聯繫我們 關於萬維
簡體 繁體 手機版
分類廣告
版主:白夫長
萬維讀者網 > 軍事天地 > 帖子
-YDX-:朝鮮戰爭真相揭秘:狠抽謊言家的耳光
送交者: -YDX- 2010年10月27日22:15:17 於 [軍事天地] 發送悄悄話
任何歷史問題,尤其是敏感的政治性問題,往往會根據政治立場存在不同的說法,而這其中往往有一方在說謊。在1990年代,接觸了一些美國的歷史書籍後,我發現中美對朝鮮戰爭的看法存在巨大的差異。核心問題是美國方面的一些觀點:(1)中國軍隊數量為美軍若干倍;(2)共軍人海戰術,被美軍擊斃上百萬;(3)共軍無理襲擊聯合國;(4)中國虐待俘虜;(5)聯合國優待俘虜;(6)一萬多志願軍戰俘自願去了台灣。帶着對這些問題的疑問,我閱讀了若干英文歷史資料。準備一勞永逸地SETTLE這些問題。

在軍事問題上,我主要參考了美軍的戰史,並與共軍戰史相比對。我發現,美軍的戰史往往只見樹木不見森林,描寫戰鬥詳細到營排一級,但戰略部署基本沒有介紹。而共軍戰史,往往戰略意圖交代非常清楚。二者正好可以互補。

在政治問題上,鑑於美國人和中國人寫的歷史明顯帶有強烈的意識形態和感情色彩,形容詞太多,我因此棄而不用,完全採取了英國人的歷史著作。關鍵問題上,為了減少爭議,我採用引用的方式,而非轉述。

經過相當長時間的努力,終於在1998年完成了《KOREAN WAR FAQ》。這個FAQ發布在網上基本成為KOREAN WAR的相關問題的定論,被很多學習朝鮮戰爭歷史的人作為參考。10多年來,不斷有人(包括訪問CMF的不少美軍人士)試圖向這個《KOREAN WAR FAQ》提出質疑,但最後都鴉雀無聲了。因此它經受了時間的考驗。此FAQ於1998年發表之後,我幾次想補充一些內容,但一直沒有時間。以下是該FAQ的目錄(鏈接)。
Korean War FAQ

Copyright(C) DXY, 1998, All rights reserved.

  1. What is the purpose of the Korean War FAQ?
  2. Why did PRC send troops to Korea?
  3. What was China's military objective in the Koren war?
  4. Did PRC warn US/UN before it sent troops?
  5. Why did PRC send troops under the name of volunteer army?
  6. When did PVA first enter Korea?
  7. What was an army in PLA unit hierarchy?
  8. How was the PLA equipment in the Korean war?
  9. What were PVA's tactics  and strategies in Korean war?
  10. Who was the PVA commander in Korea?
  11. How did PVA's strength compare to that of  US/UN forces at the second campaign?
  12. How did PVA perform in its first campaign against US/UN forces?
  13. How did PVA perform in the second campaign?
  14. How about the third PVA campaign?
  15. How did PVA perform in the 4th campaign?
  16. How about the 5th campaign?
  17. Why was PLA 180th Division lost?
  18. What happened after the 5th campaign?
  19. What was the PVA and UN numerical strength at various stages of the Korean war?
  20. What is "human wave" tactics?
  21. How many casualties did PVA suffer?
  22. How many casualties UN suffered?
  23. Why did the truce talk drag for so long?
  24. How were Chinese and NK POWs treated by US?
  25. How did Chinese treat POWs?
  26. What was the big dispute on POW repatriation?
  27. Was the "voluntary repatriation" a violation of  the Geneva Convention?
  28. If the repatriation was voluntary, why did the POWs revolt?
  29. Why were so many Chinese POWs repatriated to KMT regime in Taiwan?
  30. How many western POWs choose not to repatriate?
  31. What did Mao say about US after the Korean war?
  32. Did US consider the use the A-Bomb in Korea?
  33. As a side question, did US threaten China with nukes after the Korean war?
  34. How many civilians were killed by US forces in Korea?
  35. What was the lesson China learned from the Korean war?
  36. What is the future outlook of Sino-US relations?
0%(0)
0%(0)
標 題 (必選項):
內 容 (選填項):
實用資訊
回國機票$360起 | 商務艙省$200 | 全球最佳航空公司出爐:海航獲五星
海外華人福利!在線看陳建斌《三叉戟》熱血歸回 豪情築夢 高清免費看 無地區限制
一周點擊熱帖 更多>>
一周回復熱帖
歷史上的今天:回復熱帖
2009: 宋魯鄭:德國大選背後的西方民主政治
2009: 打擊索馬裏海盜是中國海軍百年不遇的機
2008: 哈!阿扁領導60萬人怒吼 嗆馬英九無能
2008: 亞洲股市暴跌,歐洲早盤暴跌,石油跌入
2007: 關於彭德懷和李銳之我見
2007: 民主是危害最小的選擇麼?
2006: [原創] 中國在釣魚島問題上應該認真反
2005: 日天皇曾派親屬到中國掠奪財寶
2005: 美軍募兵計劃為啥一再落空?