設萬維讀者為首頁 廣告服務 聯繫我們 關於萬維
簡體 繁體 手機版
分類廣告
版主:奇異恩典
萬維讀者網 > 彩虹之約 > 帖子
論『給我聖經經文』這塊遮羞布
送交者: oldfish 2020年12月14日23:26:13 於 [彩虹之約] 發送悄悄話

華人基督教有個壞習慣,每次等到自己拿不出證據,臉皮被扒下來剩臉骨的時候,就開始乾嚎:

給我聖經經文!不然就認錯!

(悔改哥喊太多次,就不引文了。大家自己翻閱記錄)

但是,有趣的是,你把經文給他了,他還是繼續乾嚎:

給我聖經經文!不然就認錯!

然後,你把教父給他,他仍然繼續乾嚎:

給我聖經經文!不然就認錯!

這種抱著『謊言講1000次就能變成真理』的僥倖心理,還真能吸引很多追隨者。把『唯獨聖經』偷偷的變成『乾啃聖經』。好像跟他對話的人,包括那些制定,並捍衛基督教正統信仰的教父們,和神學家們,都沒有他們懂聖經,都沒有他們『唯獨(幹啃)聖經』。這樣,才能把自己塗抹為神聖、光輝和偉大的真理捍衛者。

(Joshua,看仔細嘍!)

但是,很遺憾的,這些『幹啃聖經大師』根本都是不讀書的人,所以在那裡亂嚷嚷。所以,為了『替基督教正統教父正名』,我還是請亞他那修出場示範:

我們還是使用Schaff的《亞他那修文集》


About NPNF2-04. Athanasius: Select Works and Letters by Athanasius
Title: NPNF2-04. Athanasius: Select Works and Letters
URL: http://www.ccel.org/ccel/schaff/npnf204.html
Author(s): Athanasius
Schaff, Philip (1819-1893) (Editor)
Publisher: Grand Rapids, MI: Christian Classics Ethereal Library
Print Basis: New York: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1892
Source: Logos Inc.
Rights: Public Domain
Status: This volume has been carefully proofread and corrected.
CCEL Subjects: All; Proofed; Early Church;
LC Call no: BR60
LC Subjects: Christianity
Early Christian Literature. Fathers of the Church, etc.

這本書1083頁英文。要大家啃完再聊,確實是一種罪過!(對我的話,還行!^_^)所以,我們看看目錄吧。就看亞他那修最有名的反亞流專著《Four Orations Agaisnt Arians》的目錄:

以下是卷二(Discourse Two)的目錄:

Chapter XIV.—Texts explained; Fourthly, Hebrews iii. 2 Introduction; the Regula Fidei counter to an Arian sense of the text; which is not supported by the word ‘servant,’ nor by ‘made’ which occurs in it; (how can the Judge be among the ‘works’ which ‘God will bring into judgment?’) nor by ‘faithful;’ and is confuted by the immediate context, which is about Priesthood; and by the foregoing passage, which explains the word ‘faithful’ as meaning trustworthy, as do 1 Pet.
iv. fin. and other texts. On the whole made may safely be understood either of the divine generation or the human creation.

Chapter XV.—Texts explained; Fifthly, Acts ii. 36. The Regula Fidei must be observed; madeapplies to our Lord’s manhood; and to His manifestation; and to His office relative to us; and is relative to the Jews. Parallel instance in Gen. xxvii. 29, 37. The context contradicts the Arian interpretation.

Chapter XVI.—Introductory to Proverbs viii. 22, that the Son is not a Creature. Arian formula, a creature but not as one of the creatures; but each creature is unlike all other creatures; and no creature can create. The Word then differs from all creatures in that in which they, though otherwise differing, all agree together, as creatures; viz. in being an efficient cause; in being the one medium or instrumental agent in creation; moreover in being the revealer of the Father; and in being the object of worship.

Chapter XVII.—Introduction to Proverbs viii. 22 continued. Absurdity of supposing a Son or Word created in order to the creation of other creatures; as to the creation being unable to bear God’s immediate hand, God condescends to the lowest. Moreover, if the Son a creature, He too could not bear God’s hand, and an infinite series of media will be necessary. Objected, that, as Moses who led out the Israelites was a man, so our Lord; but Moses was not the Agent in creation:—again, that unity is found in created ministrations, but all such ministrations are defective and dependent:—again, that He learned to create, yet could God’s Wisdom need teaching? and why should He learn, if the Father worketh hitherto? If the Son was created to create us, He is for our sake, not we for His.

Chapter XVIII.—Introduction to Proverbs viii. 22 continued. Contrast between the Father’s operations immediately and naturally in the Son, instrumentally by the creatures; Scripture terms illustrative of this. Explanation of these illustrations; which should be interpreted by the doctrine of the Church; perverse sense put on them by the Arians, refuted. Mystery of Divine Generation. Contrast between God’s Word and man’s word drawn out at length. Asterius betrayed into holding two Unoriginates; his inconsistency. Baptism how by the Son as well as by the Father. On the Baptism of heretics. Why Arian worse than other heresies.

Chapter XIX.—Texts explained; Sixthly, Proverbs viii. 22. Proverbs are of a figurative nature, and must be interpreted as such. We must interpret them, and in particular this passage, by the Regula Fidei. ‘He created me’ not equivalent to ‘I am a creature.’ Wisdom a creature so far forth as Its human body. Again, if He is a creature, it is as ‘a beginning of ways,’ an office which, though not an attribute, is a consequence, of a higher and divine nature. And it is ‘for the works,’ which implied the works existed, and therefore much more He, before He was created. Also ‘the Lord’ not the Father ‘created’ Him, which implies the creation was that of
a servant.

Chapter XX.—Texts Explained; Sixthly, Proverbs viii. 22 Continued. Our Lord is said to be created ‘for the works,’ i.e. with a particular purpose, which no mere creatures are ever said to be. Parallel of Isai. xlix. 5, &c. When His manhood is spoken of, a reason for it is added; not so when His Divine Nature; Texts in proof.

Chapter XXI.—Texts Explained; Sixthly, Proverbs viii. 22, Continued. Our Lord not said in Scripture to be ‘created,’ or the works to be ‘begotten.’ ‘In the beginning’ means in the case of the works ‘from the beginning.’ Scripture passages explained. We are made by God first, begotten next; creatures by nature, sons by grace. Christ begotten first, made or created afterwards. Sense of ‘First-born of the dead;’ of ‘First-born among many brethren;’ of ‘First-born of all creation,’ contrasted with ‘Only-begotten.’ Further interpretation of ‘beginning of ways,’ and ‘for the works.’ Why a creature could not redeem; why redemption was necessary
at all. Texts which contrast the Word and the works.

Chapter XXII.—Texts Explained; Sixthly, the Context of Proverbs viii. 22 Vz. 22–30 It is right to interpret this passage by the Regula Fidei. ‘Founded’ is used in contrast to superstructure; and it implies, as in the case of stones in building, previous existence. ‘Before the world’ signifies the divine intention and purpose. Recurrence to Prov. viii. 22, and application of it to created Wisdom as seen in the works. The Son reveals the Father, first by the works, then by the

Incarnation.

以下是亞他那修在卷二中引用的經文,和花了多少章解釋該經文的記錄:

Hebrews iii. 2(1章)

Acts ii. 36(2章)

Proverbs viii. 22(7章)

這還‘只是’卷二的統計數字。

《Four Orations Agaisnt Arians》是亞他那修最重要的作品,特色之一就是:針對亞流使用的經文,逐節駁斥亞流的謬論。所以當我看見以下的論述:

對付召會調和論和成神論的異端很簡單: 拿出聖經經文根據來!repentant12/14/206442815
12/14/20012


老魚啊,你貼的那些書,我沒有讀到哪句是Joshua

有聖經根據的說耶穌人性被造。當然每個神學家可以有自己的推論,我們暫時不討論對錯。我想要看聖經直接的根據。因為這個問題是嚴肅的神學問題。就要有直接的聖經根據。

我還是認為,道成肉身是最好的直接的表達

我都快笑死了。古代聖經是『奢侈+稀缺物品』。人家看見聖經的時候,第一件事,就是拼命背經文——因為不知道下次什麼時候才能再‘摸到’聖經。所以,人家是『背了一腦袋的聖經』誒!

你們這麼搞,難道是在暗示:

1- 你們比這些古教父『背』的聖經多?

2-你們(都2000年了)比這些古教父(愛任紐可是約翰的徒孫,2世紀的後使徒教父誒!)『更了解』使徒教訓是什麼?

3-只有你們懂聖經,那些教父都『不懂』聖經?

那麼,基督教的正統教義乾脆由你們來制定算嘍!

所以,請記得,當你

夢見光屁股、光腚預示將來會發生什麼?_68解夢

的時候,聖經不是你的

Emporio Armani 男四角內褲三件組| Costco 好市多線上購物

買抗菌內褲先等等!消保官:抽查過半沒抗菌功能| 生活| 新頭殼Newtalk

給你們『遮羞』好玩的!

善哉!善哉!




0%(0)
0%(0)
    老夫雙腳站在大公教會的正統傳統之上!阿門!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (103)
  不講道理,有問不答,只為維護異端,良心何在?  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (98)
    我的良心與亞他那修同在!您不爽嗎?  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (104)
      哪個教父與召會異端為伍,必須與異端一同劈死! 明白?👈  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (65)
  老魚,基督人性受造論,推不出調和論。同意嗎??  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (108)
    扯別的沒用! 不同意就反駁。反駁不了,你認錯。多角度!  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (59)
      寫不少啊!拜讀過了 - 克利西亞 12/15/20 (77)
    人家homoousion還是撒伯流主義語言 - oldfish 12/15/20 (85)
        耶穌神人二性一個位格 - 克利西亞 12/15/20 (66)
          啟示錄沒說人(信徒)成為神或神人。對吧? - repentant 12/15/20 (59)
          不可以!非聖經用語。  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (74)
        讀羅八去吧  /無內容 - 克利西亞 12/15/20 (69)
        相反 - 克利西亞 12/15/20 (61)
      這個淺顯的茶水例子 - 調和的靈 - 克利西亞 12/15/20 (83)
    呵呵,用教父文集就可以收拾你了!要不要玩看看!?  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (80)
    亞他那修又該死了! - oldfish 12/15/20 (84)
    mingle,去《要義》找找,哥哥!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (85)
    召會異端是大方向的錯誤,想當神的錯誤。 - repentant 12/15/20 (91)
      免得被當作在唐人街洗盤子的  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (105)
      喊爽了嗎?好好讀書去!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (98)
        你還是崇拜口水  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (88)
          哇!還不睡覺哦!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (92)
    疑?你在說永生嗎?  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (116)
      不要逃避了。怕異端被劈死嗎?😁  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (87)
        不怕!一堆教父『陪被劈』!哈!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (100)
          說的就是你的口水! 快回答問題吧。  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (81)
            我們彼此互噴口水。  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (85)
  突然覺得好像在。。。。 - oldfish 12/15/20 (100)
    教你半天,你弄明白了嗎? 不要發口水貼當根據。  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (102)
      哦?了解!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (78)
    本來就是廢話連篇!何必浪費時間!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (103)
        不然,沒臉見老人家  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (76)
        我父母砸鍋賣鐵供我到北美 - oldfish 12/15/20 (92)
        一般,都是父母砸鍋賣鐵供小孩到北美讀書,拿身份的 - oldfish 12/15/20 (97)
        有些坐貨櫃來美利堅的,到後來英文都比你好!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (86)
        真的是文盲,洗盤子等級的。。。。。無語!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (100)
          等有時間,匯總一下,讓你辯論去。 - repentant 12/15/20 (91)
    亞他那修去撞牆算了!就你懂聖經!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (107)
      沒錯! 他不提供經文,就一邊去撞牆吧!😁  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (88)
        真的是文盲誒!您不是在唐人街洗盤子切菜的那種吧?!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (108)
          本人不盲信任何人,看樣子你還是你不明白。😁  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (93)
            你相信《尼西亞信經》嗎?  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (107)
              沒仔細研讀過。我對信經一樣態度,必須按聖經看。 - repentant 12/15/20 (84)
                亞他那修,萬歲!萬歲!萬萬歲!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (91)
                所以,就是『不根據制定信經的人理解信經』。活該!哈!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (107)
  看看你貼的教父貼,有多少給了經文? - repentant 12/14/20 (112)
    行!再給一段。反正,多的很,300多頁。 - oldfish 12/14/20 (105)
      這下明白了嗎? 我當然要你的經文根據。沒經文,教父也免談。  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (113)
        您不會是文盲,讀不懂書吧?又來了! - oldfish 12/15/20 (106)
          我只要經文。謝謝!  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (98)
            開宗立派,搞個Repentantism,多拽!您可以的!加油  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (102)
            建議:弄個什麼《Repentant Creed》出來得了!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (88)
            呵呵,你對聖經經文的解釋準?還是亞他那修準?  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (77)
      這支持你什麼觀點了? 找書,還用你嗎? - repentant 12/15/20 (97)
        你找的到書嗎?找的到?還用廢話啊!哈哈!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (76)
          我找的書是聖經,證明了你們的異端所在。視而不見嗎?😁  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (75)
            恩,原來亞他那修不找聖經的哦!了解了!偉大!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (81)
              他的那些錯誤,我不是貼了嗎? 你應該表態嘛,對錯?  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (90)
                找亞他那修啊!說:亞他那修大異端!別怕!可以出名的  /無內容 - oldfish 12/15/20 (98)
              那麼你就需要替他給出經文來。對吧? 他錯了,你也跟着?  /無內容 - repentant 12/15/20 (80)
                經文來了! - oldfish 12/15/20 (90)
    真煩,慢慢看啊! - oldfish 12/14/20 (88)
    典型的『不開花水仙』:)  /無內容 - oldfish 12/14/20 (95)
  當然要按照聖經來,這你也反? 沒聖經根據,算什麼?  /無內容 - repentant 12/14/20 (103)
    我就不回應這種『喊到自己爽』的廢話了!  /無內容 - oldfish 12/14/20 (95)
      就是它 - oldfish 12/14/20 (82)
  哈哈! 又是口水貼。沒用! 拿着教父反聖經? 也是奇葩。  /無內容 - repentant 12/14/20 (84)
    來,批他! - oldfish 12/14/20 (103)
  結論 - oldfish 12/14/20 (96)
標 題 (必選項):
內 容 (選填項):
實用資訊
回國機票$360起 | 商務艙省$200 | 全球最佳航空公司出爐:海航獲五星
海外華人福利!在線看陳建斌《三叉戟》熱血歸回 豪情築夢 高清免費看 無地區限制
一周點擊熱帖 更多>>
一周回復熱帖
歷史上的今天:回復熱帖
2019: 改革宗的神學是謙卑的神學
2019: 認識自己屬靈的貧乏
2018: 張首晟:科學與信仰
2018: 以利沙伯:先行者的母親
2017: 如果莫爾真的是清白的,還是有機會的:
2017: 對Moore法官敗選的一點想法
2016: (討論)舊約問題
2016: 網友討論:第一次接觸教會感覺就象學毛
2015: 一口氣讀懂伊斯蘭教歷史
2015: 王明道對聖誕節的看法(轉)