設萬維讀者為首頁 廣告服務 技術服務 聯繫我們 關於萬維
簡體 繁體 手機版
分類廣告
版主:諍友
萬維讀者網 > 教育學術 > 跟帖
Conceptually wrong
送交者: OnePlusOneIsTwo 2016月02月26日15:09:26 於 [教育學術] 發送悄悄話
回  答: 芨芨草:也談引力波芨芨草 於 2016-02-24 19:40:47
Relativity, at least, is conceptually wrong. Space is a containment, time is a measurement of state,  independent from space. There is no space-time relationship. That space is curved really means that the fields in the space are curved, not space itself. Electric magnetic wave travels in the field is curved, not straight as in Euclidean space. Fields in space shall not be considered as part of the space. 

Since Lobachevskian initiated hyperbolic space, geometry space is not just Euclidean mathematically. Space can have curvature. So it is used for modeling fields in the space. The electric magnetic wave travels in "straight lines" in the curved space. But that space is ONLY mathematical. Physically they are fields. For example, your computer screen is a potion of space. On the left, there is a mass, which creates a gravitational field, on the right there is a magnesium, which creates a magnetic field. A neutron passes your screen space, it deflected by the gravitational field, not magnetic field. An electron is deflected by the magnetic field. They are not deflected in the same curvature, because they are two different fields. If you say the space is curved, it shall be the samed curvature for all the objects in that space. If so, the curvature is a property of the space. It simply not the case. So to define space-time relationship is simply wrong concept. But it can be mathematical, and only mathematical. 



We don't even know what exactly is the gravity, and to conclude that that is gravitational wave is premature.  



0%(0)
0%(0)
  哈哈,看了這些天引力波,就看懂了這個回帖。 /無內容 - 道還 02/28/16 (1187)
    期待後續。按這個說法,空間是什麼性質呢?  /無內容 - 道還 02/28/16 (1157)
標  題 (必選項):
內  容 (選填項):
實用資訊
回國機票$360起 | 商務艙省$200 | 全球最佳航空公司出爐:海航獲五星
海外華人福利!在線看陳建斌《三叉戟》熱血歸回 豪情築夢 高清免費看 無地區限制
一周點擊熱帖 更多>>
一周回復熱帖
歷史上的今天:回復熱帖
2015: 歐陽峰:從金融危機看政府的角色(上)
2015: 背景與世界(範例解釋)
2014: 一線調查:亞裔學生早就開始作弊
2014: 在反對SCN5上,華人沒必要過分檢討
2013: 請教: 為什麼異教徒有三個不同的英文
2013: 深山蘭:偽醫學中稀奇古怪的東西(1)
2012: 宇宙大爆炸理論的困難
2012: zt:宇宙大爆炸理論完全違反相對性原理
2011: 科學家不能道聽途說,不能危言聳聽不能
2011: 楓苑夢客:司徒雷登與燕京大學