魯教授,我有篇稿子被 Foundations of Physics 退稿。編委的意見是:
Specific comments
from a member of the Editorial Board:
Although
the editorial decision is not reflected in all referee reports, an extensive
discussion of your manuscript has led us to value the referees differently. We
hope that the suggestions made by the referees will help the author find
an alternative place for publication.
我的理解:編委廣泛地討論了你的稿件,對評審報告的看法有分歧。但編委的退稿決定和評審報告無關。 。。。。
請問我的理解對不對?我寫信給 Gerard
't Hooft,說我完全能駁倒評審人的批評,修改後能否重新投稿,他老先生不理睬。很是不服氣。
謝謝。