Reasoning without logic? |
送交者: 言真轻 2009月02月27日12:34:37 于 [教育学术] 发送悄悄话 |
回 答: You mixed up things again! 由 空军大院 于 2009-02-27 12:04:46 |
Does rational people need to be logical in their reasonings as well? If a person is not logical, how could you say s/he is rational? I am totally confused here. Traditional Chinese way of thinking is not logical, so I can only say that traditionally Chinese had tried very hard to be rational, but they just could not. Because, they failed to develop something called logics. 所谓的“白马非马”论,曾被用来证明中国古代人有逻辑思维。
这也太牵强附会了,“白马非马”在我看来最多了是一种诡辩,而且是基于汉字这种落后文字的狡辩。它和同时代的用字母文字思维并表达的亚里士多德,不仅不能在思维深度上比,在语言表述上也是无可比之处的。 |
|
|
|
|
实用资讯 | |
|
|
一周点击热帖 | 更多>> |
|
|
一周回复热帖 |
|
历史上的今天:回复热帖 |
2008: | ZT: 话说何祚庥(I) | |
2008: | ZT: 话说何祚庥(II) | |
2007: | 在美国没本事的人不敢学医 | |
2007: | 追忆我的老师华罗庚-为人民服务的数学 | |
2006: | 谈谈上海交大出陈进一类人物的必然 | |
2006: | 对草根“无神论者。。。” 的看法 | |
2005: | 寒冰: 中国今天的西化到底为了谁? | |
2004: | 谈谈文章的水平 | |
2004: | 谁动了北大的奶酪 | |