设万维读者为首页 广告服务 联系我们 关于万维
简体 繁体 手机版
首页 新闻 视频 博客 论坛 分类广告 购物
版主:奇异恩典
万维读者网 > 彩虹之约 > 帖子
John Macarthur:关于全然败坏T的关键争论
送交者: 谨守 2023年12月28日19:07:39 于 [彩虹之约] 发送悄悄话

KEY CHAPTERS IN THE CONFLICT OVER TOTAL DEPRAVITY

The quintessential episode in the whole debate, of course, was the Pelagian controversy. This conflict arose early in the fifth century when Pelagius and Celestius objected to Augustine’s teaching that sinners are totally unable to obey God unless He intervenes by grace to free them from sin.

关于全然败坏的冲突的关键章节

当然,整个辩论中最典型的事件是伯拉纠之争。这场冲突发生在五世纪初,当时伯拉纠和塞莱斯蒂乌斯反对奥古斯丁的教导,即罪人完全无法顺服神,除非神通过恩典介入,将他们从罪中解放出来。

Augustine was merely affirming the plain truth of Romans 8:7–8: “The mind that is set on the flesh is hostile to God, for it does not submit to God’s law; indeed, it cannot. Those who are in the flesh cannot please God.” But according to Pelagianism, anyone who simply chooses to obey God can do so. In contradiction to Romans 5:12–19, Pelagius steadfastly denied that human nature was in any way defiled or disabled by our first parents’ sin. He insisted Adam alone fell when he ate the forbidden fruit, and neither guilt nor corruption was passed from Adam to his progeny because of his disobedience. Instead, the Pelagians said, every person possesses perfect freedom of the will just as Adam himself did at the beginning. So when we sin, it’s purely by choice, not because our nature is depraved. They furthermore said sinners have the ability to change their hearts and free themselves from sin by the exercise of sheer willpower.

奥古斯丁只是肯定了罗马书8章7-8节中的直白的真理:“原来体贴肉体的,就是与神为仇。因为不服神的律法,也是不能服。而且属肉体的人,不能得神的喜欢。”但根据伯拉纠主义,任何选择顺服神的人都能够这样做。与罗马书 5:12-19 相矛盾的是,伯拉纠坚决否认人性因我们始祖的罪而受到任何形式的玷污或残疾。他坚持认为只有亚当吃了禁果才堕落,并且亚当的罪疚和腐败都没有因为他的悖逆而传给他的后代。相反,伯拉纠派说,每个人都拥有完美的意志自由,就像亚当本人一开始所做的那样。因此,当我们犯罪时,纯粹是出于选择,而不是因为我们的本性败坏了。他们还表示,罪人有能力通过纯粹的意志力改变自己的内心,使自己摆脱罪恶。

 

In effect, the Pelagians denied the need for divine grace and reduced salvation to a shallow notion of self-reformation. Of course, they utterly failed to make any compelling rational or biblical case for such a system, and their view was formally denounced as heresy by the Council of Ephesus in 431.

实际上,伯拉纠派否认对神恩典的需要,并将救赎简化为自我改革的肤浅概念。当然,他们完全没有为这样的体系提供任何令人信服的理性或圣经依据,他们的观点在 431 年被以弗所会议正式谴责为异端。

Yet no sooner was the original wave of Pelagian teaching turned aside than a new movement arose to explain away the seriousness of human depravity—with a more subtle doctrinal sleight of hand. While formally acknowledging that Adam’s sin in some measure infected and disabled all his offspring, this view insisted that sinners nevertheless have just enough freedom of will left to make the first motion of faith toward God without the aid of divine grace. Today, we commonly refer to this view as Semi-Pelagianism, because it is something of a middle position between the views of Augustine and Pelagius. The name is a more recent coinage, dating back to the early Reformation, but the idea first arose not long after the Pelagian controversy began.

然而,最初的伯拉纠教义浪潮刚一被搁置,一场新的运动就兴起了,用更微妙的教义花招来曲解人类堕落的严重性。虽然正式承认亚当的罪在某种程度上感染了并致残了他所有的后代,但这种观点坚持认为,罪人仍然有足够的意志自由,可以在没有神恩典的帮助下对神做出最初的信仰行动。今天,我们通常将这种观点称为半伯拉纠主义,因为它介于奥古斯丁和伯拉纠的观点之间。这个名字是一个较新的造词,可以追溯到宗教改革初期,但这个想法在伯拉纠争议开始后不久就首次出现。

 

The gist of Semi-Pelagianism is that human depravity, while real, is not really total. Sinners are still good enough to be able to lay hold of saving grace on their own. Saving grace, therefore, is a response to human initiative rather than the efficient cause of our salvation.

半伯拉纠主义的要点是,人类的堕落虽然是真实的,但并不是完全的。罪人仍然足够好,能够靠自己获得拯救的恩典。因此,拯救恩典是对人类主动性的回应,而不是我们得救的有效原因。

 

The central principle underlying Semi-Pelagianism has been denounced by several church councils, starting with the Second Council of Orange in 529. But numerous influential teachers throughout church history have proposed variations and modifications, trying to avoid being labeled Pelagian or Semi-Pelagian but still seeking a way to prop up the notion that human free will is in some way the hinge on which the salvation of sinners turns.

从529年的第二次奥兰治公会议开始,半伯拉纠主义的核心原则已经被几个教会理事会谴责。但整个教会历史上许多有影响力的教师提出了变化和修改,试图避免被贴上伯拉纠主义或半伯拉纠主义的标签,但仍然寻找一种方法来支持这样一种观念,即人类自由意志在某种程度上是罪人得救的关键。

 

Arminianism takes precisely that approach. This view, of course, arose in reaction to Calvinism; it wasn’t a significant factor until some fifty years after John Calvin’s death. But in order to understand the various ways people have tried to avoid the implications of total depravity, it might be helpful to summarize Arminianism before we examine Calvin’s doctrine of total depravity in closer detail.

阿米念主义正是采用了这种方法。当然,这种观点是针对加尔文主义而产生的。直到约翰·加尔文去世大约五十年后,这才成为一个重要因素。但是,为了理解人们试图避免全然败坏的影响的各种方式,在我们更详细地研究加尔文全然败坏的教义之前,总结一下阿米念主义可能会有所帮助。

 

The Arminian position is based on a slight modification of the Semi-Pelagian principle. (In fact, many who call themselves Arminians today are actually Pelagians or Semi-Pelagians.) No true Arminian would deliberately deny that Adam’s sin left his progeny depraved and in bondage to sin. But according to the Arminian scheme, a measure of “prevenient grace” has been universally granted to sinners, nullifying or mitigating the effects of the fall. It’s not enough grace for salvation, but just enough to restore a small measure of volitional liberty to the sinner. Therefore, Arminians believe it is now possible for sinners who hear the gospel to make their own free-will choice about whether to receive it.

阿米念派的立场是基于对半伯拉纠原则的轻微修改。 (事实上,今天许多自称为阿米念主义者的人实际上是伯拉纠派或半伯拉纠派。)没有一个真正的阿民念主义者会故意否认亚当的罪导致他的后代堕落并陷入罪的束缚。但根据阿米念派的方案,罪人普遍获得了一定程度的“先行恩典”,消除或减轻了堕落的影响。这还不足以拯救罪人,但足以恢复罪人一点点的意志自由。因此,阿米念主义者相信,听到福音的罪人现在可以自由意志选择是否接受福音。

 

In other words, universal prevenient grace renders sin’s bondage moot and restores free will to the sinner. So the Arminian scheme (just like Semi-Pelagianism) gives lip service to the doctrines of original sin and humanity’s universal fallenness, but in practice it portrays the actual condition of fallen sinners as something less than total depravity.[1]

换句话说,普遍先行的恩典使罪的束缚变得毫无意义,并恢复了罪人的自由意志。因此,阿民念主义的方案(就像半伯拉纠主义一样)口头上承认原罪和人类普遍堕落的教义,但实际上它把堕落罪人的实际状况描述为并非完全败坏。

 



[1] John Macarthur, “Chapter 11: Man’s Radical Corruption,” in John Calvin: A Heart for Devotion, Doctrine, and Doxology, ed. Burk Parsons (Lake Mary, FL: Reformation Trust Publishing, 2008), 130–132.


0%(0)
  先行的恩典就是卫斯理的“杰作” - 谨守 12/29/23 (12413)
    J.I.Packer 这样说 - xiahong 12/29/23 (12412)
      抄错了地方。回家思过。一并道歉。  /无内容 - xiahong 12/29/23 (11476)
        这个认错道歉还不错。我小心谨慎一下还是对的。 - weak 12/29/23 (10637)
        为弟兄点赞。弟兄的坦诚,他们几个提鞋都不配阿 - nngzh 12/29/23 (11442)
        😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11498)
      Arminianism在《传福音与神的主权》英文版根本未出现  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11478)
      你这段话是从巴克那本书拷贝过来的,给个出处吧?  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11693)
        你准备去重新翻译?  /无内容 - xiahong 12/29/23 (11651)
          如果有必要,当然会重新翻译。但我首先想看出处,我转贴必给出处  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11619)
        J.I.Packer所著的 - xiahong 12/29/23 (11715)
          原文语态时态如何?上下文如何?我现在对中文翻译警惕了。 - weak 12/29/23 (11667)
            你颠倒黑白的本事,让我学习了  /无内容 - xiahong 12/29/23 (11582)
              请举例。  /无内容 - weak 12/29/23 (11597)
                你上面那一贴  /无内容 - xiahong 12/29/23 (11535)
                  链接在此,没有冤枉RCA吧,不是黑白颠倒吧。 - weak 12/29/23 (10675)
            希腊文和英文的冠词是一个big deal,华人翻译很容易在这 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11604)
          没贴上文章名字 - xiahong 12/29/23 (11656)
            我有这本书,你给出几章几页?  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11617)
              改革宗网站的,也能胡翻译?  /无内容 - xiahong 12/29/23 (11596)
                打着改革宗旗号的网站,要特别小心。RCA还荷兰改革宗呢, - weak 12/29/23 (11581)
                  这个网站行吗? - xiahong 12/29/23 (11544)
                    你把你拷贝的那一页的链接发上来就好,英文版的那本书 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11520)
                      您老人家这么快就通读了一遍?十戒里有撒谎吗?  /无内容 - xiahong 12/29/23 (11503)
                        撒谎的显示是你——毒蛇的种类  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11503)
                          对不起,我抄错了地方。 道歉,接受您的指教  /无内容 - xiahong 12/29/23 (11490)
                            😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11464)
                        下面很清楚显示我有电子版 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11476)
                        我有英文电子版,一搜索就知道  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11474)
      现在没人嫌弃巴克嘴大了?😁  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (12254)
        你同意巴刻的结论吗?  /无内容 - xiahong 12/29/23 (12227)
          同意他前面的,唯独最后一句不同意  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11875)
            没有同感一灵?  /无内容 - xiahong 12/29/23 (11733)
              你还是先把链接发上来吧,撒谎的人啊  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11459)
      顶 - nngzh 12/29/23 (12329)
        😄😄😄😄😄定错地方了  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11444)
    不带你这样的,他们同感一灵,主张一样,笔误而已  /无内容 - xiahong 12/29/23 (12438)
        我们是那种真正不崇拜大V的,我们一贯慎思明辨👍🏻  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11456)
        你们带头专挑大V少数字句,还不准别人仔细分辨?  /无内容 - weak 12/29/23 (11691)
      欢迎你在主帖下畅谈卫斯理的先行的恩典  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (12379)
        惭愧,我兴趣不大。  /无内容 - xiahong 12/29/23 (12366)
          没兴趣?怕是谈不出来几句话吧  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11795)
          没兴趣?怕是谈不出来几句话吧  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11810)
      是的,我们同感一灵,在P话题上我跟weak一样怒吼麦克阿瑟  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (12365)
        一共五点哟,只一点可以吗?我问过的  /无内容 - xiahong 12/29/23 (12337)
          是啊,五点一点都不放过,从第一点开始  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11850)
    有本事你就聚焦T,至于P话题,我是不会放过麦克阿瑟的  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (12401)
        我的主帖清楚表明麦克阿瑟谴责先行的恩典☝🏻  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (11436)
          俺也认为“先行的恩典”于圣经的根据不足 - nngzh 12/29/23 (11421)
            哪有你这种大傻呢?先行的恩典就是否认神恩独作啊 - 谨守 12/29/23 (10825)
    是你在蓄意玩弄花招转移视线,是你蓄意将T话题转换成P话题  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (12395)
    污老N必将像贼一样躲避这一帖,也势必继续贼溜溜地躲避  /无内容 - 谨守 12/29/23 (12695)
    一个不承认自己是罪人的人需要耶稣为他钉十字架和复活吗?  /无内容 - 谨守 12/28/23 (14449)
    果真,日光之下无新事  /无内容 - 谨守 12/28/23 (14473)
  gives lip service、 but in prac - 谨守 12/28/23 (14516)
    这百姓用嘴唇尊敬我,心却远离我(太15:8)污老N就是这种人  /无内容 - 谨守 12/28/23 (14509)
  我恭候污老N枪毙John Macarthur  /无内容 - 谨守 12/28/23 (14642)
标 题 (必选项):
内 容 (选填项):
实用资讯
回国机票$360起 | 商务舱省$200 | 全球最佳航空公司出炉:海航获五星
海外华人福利!在线看陈建斌《三叉戟》热血归回 豪情筑梦 高清免费看 无地区限制